Postspace research · November 2026 · by Bree Flemings, founder
Views Don't Pay: we read 8,155 TikTok comments to see which videos make people buy
We read 8,155 comments under 102 TikToks with 116.7 million combined views, across 12 video formats that brands and apps use to sell.
Only 98 comments (1.2%, about 1 in 83) came from someone trying to buy: asking where to get it, how much it costs, what the app is called, or saying they just bought or downloaded it.
8,155
comments read
1 in 83
asked to buy
11 : 1
jokes to buyers on the most-watched videos
The more it's watched, the less it sells
And the more a video was watched, the less of its comment section was buyers:
| Videos, by views | Views range | Buyer comments per 1,000 | Jokes per 1,000 | Praise per 1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Least-watched third (34 videos) | 860 – 60K | 21.3 | 38.6 | 357.7 |
| Middle third (34 videos) | 63K – 689K | 9.6 | 61.2 | 251.3 |
| Most-watched third (34 videos) | 700K – 9.2M | 11.3 | 126.6 | 200.5 |
On the most-watched videos, jokes outnumbered buyers 11 to 1. On the least-watched, about 2 to 1.
Five findings
1. 1 in 83 comments is a buyer
Of 8,155 comments: 98 buyers (1.2%), 353 product questions (4.3%), 1,911 praise (23.4%), 1,081 objections (13.3%), 790 jokes (9.7%), 263 social proof (3.2%), and the rest general chatter. Most of a comment section is applause, not demand.
2. Going viral fills the comments with jokes, not buyers
Buyer comments per 1,000 roughly halved from the least-watched third to the top two thirds (21.3 → 9.6–11.3), while jokes more than tripled (38.6 → 126.6). Big videos still collect more buyer comments in total, but as a share of the conversation, buyers get drowned out.
3. Format beats reach
Buyer comments per 1,000 comments read, by format:
Packing-orders POVs pulled about 4× the average buyer rate. "Stitch the Wrong Take" videos had 10.5M views and zero buyer comments in the 947 we read. ASMR process videos got 28M views but less than half the average buyer rate.
4. Before/after videos make people curious, not ready to buy
Before/after splits got the most product questions of any format (90 per 1,000, double the average) but only 2.3 buyer comments per 1,000. People asked what it was and whether it really works. They didn't ask where to buy it.
5. For apps, show the app working
Among app formats, screen recordings of the app doing its main job ("Screen-Record Aha") got 25.9 buyer comments per 1,000 ("what is the app called?", "just downloaded it"), about 4× text-on-screen and day-in-the-life app videos (6.9 and 5.8).
Bonus: the camera sells whatever is in frame. Several buyer comments asked about things in the background, not the product: the wall panel behind the creator, the shipping boxes, the glue. Viewers buy what they can see clearly.
Format beats reach
Buyer comments per 1,000 comments read, by format:
| Format | Videos | Comments read | Combined views | Buyer comments per 1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Problem → Agitate → Product | 3 | 182 | 1.4M | 49.5 |
| Packing Orders POV | 11 | 267 | 8.5M | 48.7 |
| Screen-Record Aha (apps) | 11 | 463 | 8.9M | 25.9 |
| Founder Answers the Comment | 4 | 141 | 0.1M | 21.3 |
| Three Reasons, Fast Cuts | 15 | 1,179 | 36.4M | 20.4 |
| Unboxing First Reaction | 7 | 663 | 0.7M | 13.6 |
| ASMR Process Shot | 16 | 1,957 | 28.1M | 8.7 |
| Text-First Silent Scroll (apps) | 7 | 579 | 2.9M | 6.9 |
| Day-in-the-Life With the App | 4 | 345 | 1.4M | 5.8 |
| Green-Screen Receipt | 5 | 558 | 3.2M | 5.4 |
| Before / After Split | 10 | 874 | 14.6M | 2.3 |
| Stitch the Wrong Take | 9 | 947 | 10.5M | 0 |
| All formats | 102 | 8,155 | 116.7M | 12.0 |
What buyers actually wrote
Real comments, unedited
“how much and where i can get it”
“Where can I buy this”
“Before I get invested, how much does this app cost for us to use it?”
“Just downloaded routinery. Thank you!!”
“What is the app called ?”
“cuánto cuesta el producto?”
“Do you ship to belgium”
What this means for brands and app founders
- 01
Judge a video by its comment section, not its view count. Count the comments asking where to buy, how much, or what the app is called.
- 02
Pick formats that put the product in someone's hands: packing orders, problem → product, three reasons with the product in shot. For apps, screen-record the moment it works.
- 03
Treat jokes and praise as reach, not demand. A viral video full of laughing emojis can sell less than a 20K-view video where people ask for the link.
- 04
Answer the price question before it's asked. "How much?" was one of the most common buyer comments.
Method (read this before quoting numbers)
- Videos: 102 public TikToks in Postspace's format library with at least one comment collected. They were chosen as examples of 12 formats brands and apps use (DTC/TikTok Shop products and consumer apps), not a random sample of TikTok.
- Comments: collected Aug 31 – Nov 13, 2026. Postspace reads a sample of each video's comments, not all of them: median 33 per video, average 80, maximum 1,314. Videos averaged 503 total comments.
- Classification: each comment was sorted by AI into one theme: purchase intent, product question, praise, objection, humor, social proof, tagging a friend, or other. "Buyer comment" = purchase intent: asking where to buy, the price or the app's name, or saying they just bought or downloaded it.
- Caveats: samples per format are small (3–16 videos), so treat format rankings as directional. A manual spot check found a few buyer comments asking about background items rather than the product (they're counted, and they're the "camera sells whatever is in frame" bonus finding). Views are public counts at the time we captured each video.
- Contact: Bree Flemings, founder of Postspace · postspace.app
Press
Journalists and newsletters: use any number or chart with a link to this page. Questions or the full data: marc.menkon@trypostspace.app (Postspace team) — put 'Press' in the subject.
